Category:
Created:
Updated:
Making room for disagreement
Why a community with no disagreement is usually a quiet one, and how to set norms that keep debate respectful.
New community managers often treat every disagreement as a problem to fix. But a community where nobody ever disagrees is usually one where people don't care enough to speak up. Your job is to keep disagreement safe and useful.
Set the norms early
Add two or three lines about disagreement to your guidelines while things are calm. For example: "Argue with the post, not the poster." "Assume the other person means well." "You don't need the last word." Norms written in advance feel fair; norms invented in the middle of an argument feel like taking sides.
Model it yourself
Members copy the host. When someone disagrees with you, thank them, take the point seriously and change your mind in public when they're right. The first time I wrote "fair point, we'll change that" in the Community Managers Circle, I noticed far more honest replies to my posts in the weeks after.
Know when it stops being useful
A disagreement stops being productive when people repeat themselves, switch from the topic to each other, or newer members start avoiding the thread. That's the moment to step in, summarise both positions and suggest moving on. The Moderation Essentials course covers that part in more detail.
This week's task: add one to three lines about disagreement to your community guidelines. The next time someone challenges one of your posts, thank them publicly.